| 2019 PRESEASON FCS ALL-AMERICA TEAMS | ||||
| OFFENSE | ||||
| 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM | 3rd TEAM | 4th TEAM | |
| QB | Tom Flacco, Towson, Sr. | Jake Maier, UC Davis, Sr. | Tyrie Adams, Western Carolina, Sr. | Case Cookus, Northern Arizona, Sr. |
| RB | James Robinson, Illinois St, Sr. | De’Shawn Waller, Alcorn St, Sr. | Elijah Dotson, Sacramento State, Jr. | Josh Davis, Weber St, Soph. |
| RB | A.J. Hines, Duquesne, Sr. | Pierre Strong Jr, South Dakota St, Soph. | Billy McCrary, Abilene Christian, Sr. | Quay Holmes, ETSU, Soph. |
| FB | Clint Ratkovich, Western Illinois, Jr. | Tyler Crist, William & Mary, Jr. | Luke Sellers, South Dakota St, Sr. | Troy Andersen, Montana St, Jr. |
| WR | Josh Pearson, Jacksonville St, Sr. | Bryce Nunnelly, Chattanooga, Jr. | Jequez Ezzard, Howard, Sr. | Kristian Wilkerson, Southeast Missouri, Sr. |
| WR | Cade Johnson, South Dakota St, Jr. | Nathan Stewart, Sam Houston St, Sr. | Kyle Anthony, Howard, Sr. | Shane Leatherbury, Towson, Sr. |
| WR | Aaron Parker, Rhode Island, Sr. | Michael Bandy, San Diego, Sr. | Elijah Bell, North Carolina A&T, Sr. | Mitch Gueller, Idaho St, Sr. |
| TE | Charlie Taumoepeau, Portland St, Sr. | Adam Trautman, Dayton, Sr. | Briley Moore, Northern Iowa, Sr. | Wes Preece, UC Davis, Sr. |
| OL | Zack Johnson North Dakota St, Sr. | Alex Taylor, South Carolina St, Sr. | Marcus Pettiford, North Carolina A&T, Sr. | Kevin Hall, Alcorn St, Sr. |
| OL | Zach Larsen, Southern Utah, Sr. | Spencer Blackburn, Eastern Washington, Sr. | Kyle Nunez, Stony Brook, Soph. | Hunter Watts, Central Arkansas, Sr. |
| OL | Justus Basinger, Wofford, Sr. | Drew Himmelman, Illinois St, Jr. | Liam Fornadel, James Madison, Jr. | Liam Dobson, Maine, Jr. |
| OL | Kyle Murphy, Rhode Island, Sr. | Dieter Eiselen, Yale, Sr. | Mitch Brott, Montana St, Sr. | Mark Williamson, William & Mary, Sr. |
| OL | Noah Johnson, Idaho, Sr. | J’Von Brown, Central Connecticut St, Sr. | Ty Whitworth, Weber St, Jr. | Jake Marotti, Lafayette, Sr. |
| DEFENSE | ||||
| 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM | 3rd TEAM | 4th TEAM | |
| DL | Nasir Player, ETSU, Sr. | John Daka, James Madison, Sr. | Darin Greenfield, South Dakota, Sr. | Derrek Tuszka, North Dakota St, Sr. |
| DL | Nick Wheeler, Colgate, Sr. | Ron’Dell Carter, James Madison, Sr. | Sully Laiche, Nicholls, Sr. | Mason Bennett, North Dakota, Sr. |
| DL | Aaron Patrick, Eastern Kentucky, Sr. | Jonah Williams, Weber St, Sr. | Anthony Knighton, Southern Illinois, Jr. | Kayon Whitaker, Maine, Sr. |
| DL | Maurice Jackson, Richmond, Sr. | Khristian Tate, Georgetown, Sr. | Bill Murray, William & Mary, Sr. | Jalen Goss, Northern Arizona, Sr. |
| LB | Dante Olson, Montana, Sr. | Jonas Griffith, Indiana St, Sr. | Bryce Sterk, Montana St, Sr. | Bryson Armstrong, Kennesaw St, Jr. |
| LB | Zach Hall, Southeast Missouri, Sr. | Adrian Hope, Furman, Soph. | Jeremiah Chambers, Abilene Christian, Sr. | Justin Swift, Southeast Missouri, Sr. |
| LB | Jabril Cox, North Dakota St, Jr. | Christian Rozeboom, South Dakota St, Sr. | Evan Veron, Nicholls, Sr. | Dimitri Holloway, James Madison, Sr. |
| LB | Cameron Gill, Wagner, Sr. | Solomon Muhammad, Alcorn St, Sr. | Glenn Cunningham, Fordham, Jr. | Da’Jon Lee, Saint Francis, Sr. |
| DB | Isiah Swann, Dartmouth, Sr. | Rashad Robinson, James Madison, Sr. | Greg Liggs Jr., Elon, Sr. | Alize Ward, Stephen F. Austin, Sr. |
| DB | Marlon Bridges, Jacksonville St, Sr. | Luther Kirk, Illinois State, Sr. | Abu Daramy-Swaray, Colgate, Sr. | Mac McCain III, North Carolina A&T St, Jr. |
| DB | Manny Patterson, Maine, Sr. | Gavin Heslop, Stony Brook, Sr. | Will Warner, Drake, Jr. | Zyon McCollum, Sam Houston, Jr. |
| DB | Jeremy Chinn, Southern Illinois, Sr. | Dajour Nesbeth, Tennessee St, Sr. | Tyree Robinson, ETSU, Jr. | Dorian Walker, Kennesaw St, Sr. |
| SPECIAL TEAMS | ||||
| 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM | 3rd TEAM | 4th TEAM | |
| K | Grayson Atkins, Furman, Jr. | Aidan O’Neill, Towson, Sr. | Ethan Ratke, James Madison, Jr. | Jerry Nunez, Indiana St, Sr. |
| P | Alex Pechin, Bucknell, Sr. | Chris Faddoul, Florida A&M, Jr. | Cade Coffey, Idaho, Jr. | Garret Wegner, North Dakota St, Jr. |
| KR | Rashid Shaheed, Weber St, Jr. | Ahmere Dorsey, Rhode Island, Sr. | Judd Cockett, Southern Utah, Soph. | Isaac Foster, Kennesaw St, Soph. |
| PR | D’Angelo Amos, James Madison, Jr. | Nick Rinella, Saint Francis (PA), Sr. | Mike Roussos, Columbia, Soph. | Chris Rowland, Tennessee St, Sr. |
| LS | Bradey Sorenson, South Dakota St, Jr. | Billy Barber, Stony Brook, Sr. | Chandler Collins, Missouri St, Sr. | Tucker Addington, Sam Houston St, Sr. |
