| Phil Steele's 2019 Preseason All-CAA Teams | |||
| OFFENSE | |||
| 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM | 3rd TEAM | |
| QB | Tom Flacco, Towson, Sr. | Ben DiNucci, James Madison, Sr. | Davis Cheek, Elon, Jr. |
| RB | Jaylan Thomas, Elon, Soph. | Karl Mofor, Albany, Jr. | Dejoun Lee, Delaware, Jr. |
| RB | Shane Simpson, Towson, Sr. | Percy Agyei-Obese, James Madison, Jr. | Carlos Washington Jr, New Hampshire, Soph. |
| FB | Tyler Crist, William & Mary, Jr. | Yeedee Thaenrat, Towson, Sr. | Joey Kenny, Rhode Island, Sr. |
| WR | Aaron Parker, Rhode Island, Sr. | Riley Stapleton, James Madison, Sr. | Kyndel Dean, James Madison, Soph. |
| WR | Shane Leatherbury, Towson, Sr. | Jabari Allen, Towson, Jr. | Jaquan Blair, Maine, Sr. |
| WR | Earnest Edwards, Maine, Sr. | Dev Holmes, Albany, Soph. | Andre Miller, Maine, Jr. |
| TE | Dylan Stapleton, James Madison, Sr. | Matt Foster, Elon, Sr. | Simon Bingelis, Villanova, Sr. |
| OL | Kyle Murphy, Rhode Island, Sr. | Jahee Jackson, James Madison, Sr. | Mason Zimmerman, Stony Brook, Sr. |
| OL | Liam Fornadel, James Madison, Jr. | Mario Farinella, Delaware, Sr. | Riley Burns, New Hampshire, Soph. |
| OL | Kyle Nunez, Stony Brook, Soph. | Mac Patrick, James Madison, Sr. | Chris Mulvey, Maine, Jr. |
| OL | Liam Dobson, Maine, Jr. | Aaron Grzymkowski, Towson, Jr. | Zaire Bethea, James Madison, Jr. |
| OL | Mark Williamson, William & Mary, Sr. | David Kroll, Delaware, Jr. | Tim Coleman, Richmond, Jr. |
| DEFENSE | |||
| 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM | 3rd TEAM | |
| DL | Ron’Dell Carter, James Madison, Sr. | Bill Murray, William & Mary, Sr. | Malik Fisher, Villanova, Jr. |
| DL | Kayon Whitaker, Maine, Sr. | Sam Kamara, Stony Brook, Sr. | Tez Wilson, Rhode Island, Sr. |
| DL | John Daka, James Madison, Sr. | Charles Mitchell, Maine, Sr. | Bryce Carter, Towson, Jr. |
| DL | Maurice Jackson, Richmond, Sr. | Marcus Willoughby, Elon, Sr. | Brandon Ginnetti, Rhode Island, Sr. |
| LB | Deshawn Stevens, Maine, Jr. | Nate Atkins, William & Mary, Sr. | Landan Word, James Madison, Sr. |
| LB | Dimitri Holloway, James Madison, Sr. | Ricky DeBerry, Towson, Sr. | Levi Metheny, Albany, Jr. |
| LB | Robert Heyward, Towson, Sr. | Keon Paye, Towson, Sr. | Eli Mencer, Albany, Sr. |
| LB | Taji Lowe, Maine, Sr. | Drew Wiley, Villanova, Sr. | Branyan Javier-Castillo, Rhode Island, Sr. |
| DB | Manny Patterson, Maine, Sr. | Pop Lacey, New Hampshire, Sr. | Daniel Jones, Richmond, Sr. |
| DB | Rashad Robinson, James Madison, Sr. | Adam Smith, James Madison, Sr. | Jaquan Amos, Villanova, Jr. |
| DB | Greg Liggs Jr, Elon, Sr. | Isaiah Laster, William & Mary, Sr. | Christian Benford, Villanova, Soph. |
| DB | Gavin Heslop, Stony Brook, Sr. | Daniel Reid-Bennett, Elon, Sr. | Corey Parker, William & Mary, Sr. |
| SPECIAL TEAMS | |||
| 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM | 3rd TEAM | |
| K | Aidan O’Neill, Towson, Sr. | Ethan Ratke, James Madison, Jr. | Skyler Davis, Elon, Soph. |
| P | Nick Pritchard, Delaware, Sr. | Harry O’Kelly, James Madison, Jr. | Drew Sanborn, New Hampshire, Sr. |
| KR | Ahmere Dorsey, Rhode Island, Sr. | Earnest Edwards, Maine, Sr. | Shane Simpson, Towson, Sr. |
| PR | D’Angelo Amos, James Madison, Jr. | Ahmere Dorsey, Rhode Island, Sr. | Shane Simpson, Towson, Sr. |
| LS | Billy Barber, Stony Brook, Sr. | Kyle Davis, James Madison, Soph. | Tristan Sokach-Minnick, Albany, Jr. |
| 2019 PRESEASON CAA OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: QB Tom Flacco, Towson, Sr. | |||
| 2019 PRESEASON CAA DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: LB Dimitri Holloway, James Madison, Sr. | |||
