| Phil Steele's 2019 Preseason All-Pioneer League Teams | |||
| OFFENSE | |||
| 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM | 3rd TEAM | |
| QB | Calvin Turner Jr, Jacksonville, Jr. | Jack Cook, Dayton, Soph. | Gaven DeFilippo, Stetson, Sr. |
| RB | Wesley Dugger, Davidson, Jr. | Jareem Westcott, Stetson, Soph. | Brad Sznajder, Butler, Sr. |
| RB | Will Wicks, Davidson, Sr. | Emilio Martinez, San Diego, Jr. | Irvin Riley, Jacksonville, Sr. |
| FB | Jorell Story, Davidson, Sr. | Garnet Nicolas, Jacksonville, Soph. | Grant Hodges, Stetson, Jr. |
| WR | Michael Bandy, San Diego, Sr. | William Wicks, Davidson, Sr. | Justin Jordan, Stetson, Jr. |
| WR | Steven Doran, Drake, Sr. | Ryan Skibinski, Dayton, Sr. | Anthony Olivencia, Marist, Sr. |
| WR | Steve Burdette, Stetson, Sr. | Devin Cates, Drake, Sr. | Stephen Dennis, Butler, Sr. |
| TE | Adam Trautman, Dayton, Sr. | Jon Kanda, Marist, Sr. | Dalton Kincaid, San Diego, Soph. |
| OL | Jake Michaels, San Diego, Sr. | Jacob Bacon, Drake, Jr. | Alex Brown, Stetson, Jr. |
| OL | Josh Poe, Morehead St, Sr. | Bradley Alexander, Stetson, Jr. | Justin Karem, Dayton, Sr. |
| OL | Dane Cordell, Jacksonville, Jr. | Michael Niese, Dayton, Jr. | Cam Bailey, Morehead St, Sr. |
| OL | Dan Wittekind, Marist, Sr. | Aidan Valencia, San Diego, Sr. | Jacob Brunson, Dayton, Soph. |
| OL | Ethan Steinbacher, Davidson, Sr. | Jack Jarnigan, Valparaiso, Sr. | John McArthur, Butler, Sr. |
| DEFENSE | |||
| 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM | 3rd TEAM | |
| DL | Bryce Perry-Martin, Davidson, Sr. | Gavin Dineen, Drake, Jr. | Crandall Maines, Jacksonville, Sr. |
| DL | Nick Friedel, San Diego, Jr. | Erin Morgan, Drake, Sr. | Vaughn Taylor, Morehead St, Jr. |
| DL | Jacob Bergstrom, San Diego, Jr. | Fermon Reid, Stetson, Soph. | Kevin Glajchen, San Diego, Sr. |
| DL | Mickey Kane, Butler, Soph. | James Reed, Valparaiso, Sr. | Mike Stodola, Dayton, Soph. |
| LB | Colby Duncan, Stetson, Sr. | Maliek Carr, Marist, Sr. | Grant Dixon, Marist, Sr. |
| LB | Austin Petrie, Valparaiso, Sr. | Mason Brunner, Butler, Sr. | Caysaun Wakeley, Jacksonville, Sr. |
| LB | Andrew Lutgens, Dayton, Jr. | Zac Rujawitz, Drake, Sr. | Jamieson Craske, Stetson, Sr. |
| LB | Kama Kamaka, San Diego, Jr. | Tony Collins, Davidson, Sr. | Tarren Smith II, Stetson, Sr. |
| DB | Will Warner, Drake, Jr. | Rayshawn McCall, Davidson, Sr. | Reggie Gantt, Stetson, Sr. |
| DB | JJ Henderson, Stetson, Jr. | Dreylan Hines, Davidson, Soph. | Jalon Scott, Stetson, Sr. |
| DB | David Tolbert, San Diego, Sr. | CJ Lewis, Jacksonville, Sr. | Justice Seales, Marist, Jr. |
| DB | Luke Sennett, Butler, Sr. | Jamari Booker, Valparaiso, Sr. | TJ Coley, Jacksonville, Jr. |
| SPECIAL TEAMS | |||
| 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM | 3rd TEAM | |
| K | Jonny Messina, Stetson, Jr. | Drew Bevelhimer, Butler, Sr. | Dimitrios Latsonas, Valparaiso, Sr. |
| P | Tanner Kuljian, San Diego, Sr. | Andrew Foster, Morehead St, Jr. | Ross Kennedy, Drake, Jr. |
| KR | Michael Armstead, San Diego, Sr. | Bailey Gessinger, Valparaiso, Sr. | Mekhai Johnson, Marist, Jr. |
| PR | Kyle Butz, Dayton, Jr. | Ian Holder, Morehead St, Soph. | JJ Henderson, Stetson, Jr. |
| LS | Mason Brunner, Butler, Sr. | Joe Giordano, Marist, Jr. | Colin Wray, Stetson, Soph. |
| 2019 PRESEASON PIONEER LEAGUE OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: TE Adam Trautman, Dayton, Sr. | |||
| 2019 PRESEASON PIONEER LEAGUE DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: SS Will Warner, Drake, Jr. | |||
