| Phil Steele's 2020-21 FCS All-America Teams | |||
| OFFENSE | |||
| 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM | 3rd TEAM | |
| QB | Eric Barriere, Eastern Washington, Sr. | Eric Schmid, Sam Houston St, Jr. | Cole Kelley, Southeastern Louisiana, Sr. |
| RB | Pierre Strong, South Dakota St, Jr. | Otis Weah, North Dakota, Soph. | Percy Ageyi-Obese, James Madison, Sr. |
| RB | Julius Chestnut, Sacred Heart, Jr. | Dejoun Lee, Delaware, Sr. | Juwon Farri, Monmouth, Soph. |
| FB | Hunter Luepke, North Dakota St, Soph. | Nathan Walker, Wofford, Jr. | Logan Kendall, Idaho, Jr. |
| WR | Jakob Herres, VMI, Jr. | Avante Cox, Southern Illinois, Jr. | Tanner Conner, Idaho, Sr. |
| WR | Tyler Hudson, Central Arkansas, Soph. | Talolo Limu-Jones, Eastern Washington, Sr. | Abdul-Fatai Ibrahim, Alabama A&M, Soph. |
| WR | Jequez Ezzard, Sam Houston St, Sr. | DeAngelo Wilson, Austin Peay, Sr. | Dai’Jean Dixon, Nicholls, Sr. |
| TE | Trae Barry, Jacksonville St, Sr. | Ryan Miller, Furman, Jr. | Rodney Williams II, UT Martin, Sr. |
| OL | Garret Greenfield, South Dakota St, Soph. | Drew Himmelman, Illinois St, Sr. | Brian Foley, Holy Cross, Sr. |
| OL | Tristen Taylor, Eastern Washington, Sr. | Raymond Gillespie, James Madison, Sr. | Tre’mond Shorts, ETSU, Jr. |
| OL | Ty Whitworth, Weber St, Sr. | David Kroll, Delaware, Sr. | Tylan Grable, Jacksonville St, Soph. |
| OL | Cordell Volson, North Dakota St, Sr. | P.J. Burkhalter, Nicholls, Sr. | J.D. DiRenzo, Sacred Heart, Sr. |
| OL | Braxton Jones, Southern Utah, Jr. | Kyle Nunez, Stony Brook, Jr. | Colby Thomas, Sam Houston St, Sr. |
| DEFENSE | |||
| 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM | 3rd TEAM | |
| DL | Isaiah Chambers, McNeese, Sr. | Mike Greene, James Madison, Sr. | Jevon Leon, Sam Houston St, Soph. |
| DL | Jared Brinkman, Northern Iowa, Sr. | Kobie Turner, Richmond, Jr. | Kevin Glajchen, San Diego, Sr. |
| DL | Jordan Lewis, Southern, Jr. | Jahari Kay, Sam Houston St, Sr. | Spencer Waege, North Dakota St, Jr. |
| DL | DJ Coleman, Jacksonville St, Jr. | Devonnsha Maxwell, Chattanooga, Jr. | John Ridgeway, Illinois St, Jr. |
| LB | Colby Campbell, Presbyterian, Sr. | Storey Jackson, Prairie View A&M, Sr. | Conner Mortensen, Weber St, Sr. |
| LB | Bryson Armstrong, Kennesaw St, Sr. | Titus Leo, Wagner, Jr. | Jared Folks, ETSU, Sr. |
| LB | Stone Snyder, VMI, Soph. | La’akea Kaho’ohanohano-Davis, Southern Utah, Jr. | Logan Backhaus, South Dakota St, Sr. |
| LB | Tre Walker, Idaho, Jr. | James Kaczor, North Dakota St, Jr. | Ryan Greenhagen, Fordham, Jr. |
| DB | Nicario Harper, Jacksonville St, Soph. | Kordell Jackson, Austin Peay, Sr. | Qua Brown, Southern Illinois, Sr. |
| DB | Robert Rochell, Central Arkansas, Sr. | Decobie Durant, South Carolina St, Jr. | Brandon Barbee, Morehead St, Jr. |
| DB | Zyon McCollum, Sam Houston St, Sr. | Ferlando Jordan, Southeastern Louisiana, Jr. | Don Gardner, South Dakota St, Sr. |
| DB | James Ceasar, Southern Illinois, Sr. | Kedrick Whitehead, Delaware, Jr. | Jordan Perryman, UC Davis, Jr. |
| SPECIAL TEAMS | |||
| 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM | 3rd TEAM | |
| K | Ethan Ratke, James Madison, Sr. | Luis Aguilar, Northern Arizona, Sr. | Mitchell Fineran, Samford, Jr. |
| P | Daniel Whelan, UC Davis, Sr. | Garret Wegner, North Dakota St, Sr. | Cade Coffey, Idaho, Sr. |
| KR | Christian Watson, North Dakota St, Jr. | Rashid Shaheed, Weber St, Sr. | Cameron Myers, Central Arkansas, Soph. |
| PR | Jequez Ezzard, Sam Houston St, Sr. | Devron Harper, Gardner-Webb, Jr. | Tyrin Ralph, Arkansas-Pine Bluff, Sr. |
| AP | Javon Williams, Southern Illinois, Soph. | Quay Holmes, ETSU, Jr. | Kevin Brown, UIW, Sr. |
| LS | Kyle Davis, James Madison, Jr. | Ross Kennelly, North Dakota St, Sr. | Robert Soderholm, VMI, Soph. |
| 2020-21 SPRING FCS OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: QB Eric Barriere, Eastern Washington, Sr. | |||
| 2020-21 SPRING FCS DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: DE Isaiah Chambers, McNeese, Sr. | |||
| 2020-21 SPRING FCS FRESHMAN OF THE YEAR: QB Mark Gronowski, South Dakota St | |||
| 2020-21 SPRING FCS OFFENSIVE LINEMAN OF THE YEAR: OT Cordell Volson, North Dakota St, Sr. | |||
| 2020-21 SPRING FCS SPECIAL TEAMS PLAYER OF THE YEAR: K Ethan Ratke, James Madison, Sr. | |||
| 2020-21 SPRING FCS PLAYOFF MVP: WR Jequez Ezzard, Sam Houston St, Sr. and RB Isaiah Davis, South Dakota St, Soph. | |||
| 2020-21 SPRING FCS COACH OF THE YEAR: K.C. Keeler, Sam Houston St | |||
