Phil Steele's 2014 Postseason All-Independent Team
| OFFENSE | |
| 1st TEAM | |
| QB | Keenan Reynolds, Navy |
| RB | Larry Dixon, Army |
| RB | Noah Copeland, Navy |
| WR | Will Fuller, Notre Dame |
| WR | Mitch Mathews, BYU |
| WR | Jordan Leslie, BYU |
| TE | Ben Koyack, Notre Dame |
| OL | Tejan Koroma, BYU |
| OL | Jake Zuzek, Navy |
| OL | Ronnie Stanley, Notre Dame |
| OL | De’Ondre Wesley, BYU |
| OL | Matt Hugenberg, Army |
| DEFENSE | |
| 1st TEAM | |
| DL | Jarron Jones, Notre Dame |
| DL | Sheldon Day, Notre Dame |
| DL | Will Anthony, Navy |
| LB | Jaylon Smith, Notre Dame |
| LB | Jeremy Timpf, Army |
| LB | Bronson Kaufusi, BYU |
| LB | Jordan Drake, Navy |
| LB | Joe Schmidt, Notre Dame |
| DB | Josh Jenkins, Army |
| DB | Cole Luke, Notre Dame |
| DB | Robertson Daniel, BYU |
| DB | Skye PoVey, BYU |
| SPECIAL TEAMS | |
| 1st TEAM | |
| K | Trevor Samson, BYU |
| P | Scott Arellano, BYU |
| KR | Adam Hine, BYU |
| PR | Cody Riggs, Notre Dame |