| OVC All Conference Teams |
| OFFENSE |
| |
1st TEAM |
2nd TEAM |
3rd TEAM |
| QB |
JaVaughn Craig, Austin Peay, Sr. |
Zerrick Cooper, Jacksonville St, Jr. |
Bailey Fisher, Tennessee Tech, Soph. |
| RB |
Daryl McCleskey Jr., Eastern Kentucky, Sr. |
Peyton Logan, UT Martin, Jr. |
Zion Custis, Southeast Missouri St, Soph. |
| RB |
Kentel Williams, Austin Peay, Sr. |
Alonzo Booth, Eastern Kentucky, Soph. |
Michael Matthews, Jacksonville St, Soph. |
| WR |
Chris Rowland, Tennessee St, Sr. |
Josh Pearson, Jacksonville St, Sr. |
LaMartez Brooks, Murray St, Soph. |
| WR |
Kristian Wilkerson, Southeast Missouri St, Sr. |
Steven Newbold, Tennessee St, Sr. |
Baniko Harley, Austin Peay, Jr. |
| WR |
DeAngelo Wilson, Austin Peay, Jr. |
Jamari Hester, Jacksonville St, Sr. |
Aaron Alston, Southeast Missouri St, Soph. |
| TE |
Colton Dowell, UT Martin, Soph. |
James Sheehan, Eastern Illinois, Sr. |
Trae Berry, Jacksonville St, Jr. |
| OL |
Kyle Anderton, Austin Peay, Sr. |
Raekwon Allen, Tennessee St, Sr. |
Tucker Schroeder, Eastern Kentucky, Soph. |
| OL |
Elijah Swehla, Southeast Missouri St, Sr. |
Aries Davis, UT Martin, Jr. |
Mike Rhoades, Tennessee Tech, Jr. |
| OL |
Blake Mitchell, Austin Peay, Jr. |
Graham Ashkettle, Eastern Kentucky, Soph. |
Bucky Williams, Austin Peay, Fr. |
| OL |
Lachavious Simmons, Tennessee St, Sr. |
Tom Burton, Tennessee St, Sr. |
Michael Shaddix, Jacksonville St, Soph. |
| OL |
Darius Anderson, Jacksonville St, Sr. |
Cam Carter, Murray St, Sr. |
Caleb Florence, Austin Peay, Jr. |
| DEFENSE |
| |
1st TEAM |
2nd TEAM |
3rd TEAM |
| DL |
Aaron Patrick, Eastern Kentucky, Sr. |
Austin Pickett, UT Martin, Sr. |
Terrell Greer, Eastern Illinois, Sr. |
| DL |
Josephus Smith, Austin Peay, Jr. |
DJ Coleman, Jacksonville St, Soph. |
Henry Karimu, Tennessee Tech, Jr. |
| DL |
Shaun Whittinghill, Austin Peay, Sr. |
Scotty Humpich, Murray St, Soph. |
John Wesley Whiteside, Austin Peay, Soph. |
| DL |
Taquan Evans, Eastern Kentucky, Sr. |
Chris Tucker, Tennessee Tech, Jr. |
Josh Avery, Southeast Missouri St, Sr. |
| LB |
Zach Hall, Southeast Missouri St, Sr. |
Jack McDonald, Austin Peay, Soph. |
Patrick Walker, Austin Peay, Sr. |
| LB |
Anthony Koclanakis, Murray St, Jr. |
Dytarious Johnson, Eastern Illinois, Jr. |
Zack Woodard, Jacksonville St, Soph. |
| LB |
Justin Swift, Southeast Missouri St, Sr. |
Cecil Cherry, UT Martin, Sr. |
Steven Crowder, Eastern Kentucky, Jr. |
| LB |
TJ Jefferson, UT Martin, Sr. |
Aderick Moore, Tennessee Tech, Sr. |
Jalen Choice, Jacksonville St, Sr. |
| DB |
Kordell Jackson, Austin Peay, Jr. |
Nigel Walton, Murray St, Sr. |
Traco Williams, Jacksonville St, Sr. |
| DB |
Marlon Bridges, Jacksonville St, Sr. |
Bydarrius Knighten, Southeast Missouri St, Jr. |
DaVonte Maura, UT Martin, Sr. |
| DB |
Nick Harper Jr, Tennessee St, Jr. |
JaQuez Akins, UT Martin, Jr. |
TJ Warren, Murray St, Sr. |
| DB |
Juantarius Bryant, Austin Peay, Sr. |
DJ Freeman, Southeast Missouri St, Sr. |
Dajour Nesbeth, Tennessee St, Sr. |
| SPECIAL TEAMS |
| |
1st TEAM |
2nd TEAM |
3rd TEAM |
| K |
Samuel Hayworth, Eastern Kentucky, Sr. |
Antonio Zita, Tennessee St, Soph. |
Haidar Zaidan, Tennessee Tech, Sr. |
| P |
Jason Pierce, Jacksonville St, Soph. |
Kaleb Mosley, Tennessee St, Soph. |
Steve Dawson, Murray St, Sr. |
| KR |
Metrius Fleming, Tennessee Tech, Fr. |
Quentin Pringle, Eastern Kentucky, Fr. |
Chris Rowland, Tennessee St, Sr. |
| PR |
Terry Williams, UT Martin, Sr. |
Chris Rowland, Tennessee St, Sr. |
Zack Smith, Southeast Missouri St, Jr. |
| AP |
Chris Rowland, Tennessee St, Sr. |
Terry Williams, UT Martin, Sr. |
Peyton Logan, UT Martin, Jr. |
| LS |
Josh Brady, Jacksonville St, Sr. |
Thomas Newberg, Tennessee St, Sr. |
Alex Shelton, Eastern Kentucky, Sr. |
| |
| 2019 OVC OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: WR Chris Rowland, Tennessee St, Sr. |
| 2019 OVC DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR: CB Kordell Jackson, Austin Peay, Jr. |
| 2019 OVC FRESHMAN OF THE YEAR: QB John Bachus III, UT Martin |
| 2019 OVC OFFENSIVE LINEMAN OF THE YEAR: OT Kyle Anderton, Austin Peay, Sr. |
| 2019 OVC SPECIAL TEAMS PLAYER OF THE YEAR: KR/PR Chris Rowland, Tennessee St, Sr. |
| 2019 OVC COACH OF THE YEAR: Mark Hudspeth, Austin Peay |
